massimilianogoi on 22/4/2010 at 08:32
Quote Posted by dethtoll
Thrash metal is now prog? Shit, who knew?
As usual, we tend to LABEL a band for any songs they have made. In this case I meant prog this only song. Listen it, dethtoll, and after tell me if isn't progressive rock.
Quote Posted by fett
...These guys had no soul, but they could play fast, complicated stuff...
:wot: I hope I have not understood right... If you meant that progressive rocker were without soul, but they played very fast, then you make a big, BIG mistake, pal! This is the aberration of the though brought by shit bands like Dream Theater. Who preferred making eight thousands notes instead of concentrating on beautifuly melodies, and from here the common (wrong) sense that progressive rock is without soul. Try to listen Genesis's "Supper's Ready", or Marillion's "Cinderella's Search", and you will get a whole different idea.
Vae on 22/4/2010 at 10:49
Pink Floyd
Led Zepplin
Black Sabbath
Iron Maiden
Rush (of course)
Queensryche
Yngwie Malmsteen
Dream Theater
Shadow Gallery
Symphony X
Pagan's Mind
Circus Maximus
massimilianogoi on 22/4/2010 at 10:59
Quote Posted by Vae
...
Iron Maiden
...
Funny that you inserted them. In facts, pieces like "Fear Of The Dark" or A"fraid To Shoot Stranger" comprehends alot of ryhtm variations, but we still can't call this progressive rock, that's a good paradox.
frozenman on 22/4/2010 at 11:21
(
http://a4esl.org/) This is the most intense prog of all time
massimilianogoi on 22/4/2010 at 12:25
Quote Posted by frozenman
(
http://a4esl.org/) This is the most intense prog of all time
Man, your spam isn't very welcomed, indeed!
fett on 22/4/2010 at 13:37
Quote Posted by massimilianogoi
As usual, we tend to LABEL a band for any songs they have made. In this case I meant prog this only song. Listen it, dethtoll, and after tell me if isn't progressive rock.
:wot: I hope I have not understood right... If you meant that progressive rocker were without soul, but they played very fast, then you make a big, BIG mistake, pal! This is the aberration of the though brought by shit bands like Dream Theater. Who preferred making eight thousands notes instead of concentrating on beautifuly melodies, and from here the common (wrong) sense that progressive rock is without soul. Try to listen Genesis's "Supper's Ready", or Marillion's "Cinderella's Search", and you will get a whole different idea.
Yeah, you misunderstood. I wasn't talking about genuine, purposeful prog bands like Genesis or Marrillion, who are both technically proficient and melodic. I meant that the average metal band in the 80's or early 90's were much, much better musicians than the average metal/rock band today. In that sense, bands like Maiden, Queensryche, or Testament might be considered "prog" by people who don't know better, simply because they play more technically complicated music than most current metal bands (possible exceptions Mutiny Within, Soilwork, etc.)
Vae - I like your list :thumb:
massimilianogoi on 22/4/2010 at 14:00
Quote Posted by fett
Yeah, you misunderstood. I wasn't talking about genuine, purposeful prog bands like Genesis or Marrillion, who are both technically proficient and melodic. I meant that the average metal band in the 80's or early 90's were much, much better musicians than the average metal/rock band today. In that sense, bands like Maiden, Queensryche, or Testament might be considered "prog" by people who don't know better, simply because they play more technically complicated music than most current metal bands (possible exceptions Mutiny Within, Soilwork, etc.)
Oh yeah, now it sounds good!
june gloom on 22/4/2010 at 18:06
Quote Posted by massimilianogoi
As usual, we tend to LABEL a band for any songs they have made. In this case I meant prog this only song. Listen it, dethtoll, and after tell me if isn't progressive rock.
I've heard the song a hundred times- I like early Metallica, remember? It's thrash. It's unusually complex thrash for Metallica, but it's still thrash. That doesn't make it a BAD song- it's one of Metallica's best.
Quote Posted by massimilianogoi
Man, your spam isn't very welcomed, indeed!
That wasn't spam, he was insulting you. To be fair, your English is slowly but surely improving.
massimilianogoi on 22/4/2010 at 19:48
Quote Posted by dethtoll
I've heard the song a hundred times- I like early Metallica, remember? It's thrash. It's unusually complex thrash for Metallica, but it's still thrash. That doesn't make it a BAD song- it's one of Metallica's best.
"One" is thrash??? O_o
Quote Posted by dethtoll
That wasn't spam, he was insulting you. To be fair, your English is slowly but surely improving.
Lol. At last you noticed that >=D
june gloom on 22/4/2010 at 19:52
Christ, of course it's thrash. What else would it be?
