LarryG on 18/10/2009 at 04:27
I have finally given up on making air cooling work with my rig:
Code:
ASUS, L1N64-SLI WS, 2x LGA1207FX, nForce 680a SLI, DDR2-800 ECC 8GB /4, PCIe x16 SLI, SATA RAID 5 /13, HDA, 2x GbLAN /2, ATX
2X AMD, Athlon™ 64 FX-74 3.0GHz Dual-Core, LGA1207, HT 2000MHz, 2MB (2 x 1MB) L2 cache, 125.0W, 90nm
2X MICROSTAR, NX8800GTS-T2D512E OC, GeForce® 8800GTS 730MHz, 512MB DDR3 1944MHz, PCIe x16 SLI, DVI /2, HDTV-Out with SLI bridge between
2X 120mm case fans
3X 80mm case fans
2X ZALMAN, CNPS8700 LED Copper CPU Cooler, Socket 754/775/939/940/AM2, Blue LED
After trying 6 different CPU air-based cooler pairs over the past 12 months, my CPU temps remain between 63C (no load) and 78C (high load) with intermittent crashes due to excessively high temps. (The (
http://products.amd.com/en-us/DesktopCPUDetail.aspx?id=21) max temp recommended by AMD for this CPU is 56C.) And this is without any overclocking!!
So I have decided to throw in the towel and try liquid cooling. Any suggestions? Manufacturers to stay away from? Ones with good reputations? I'm current seriously considering Koolance's or (
http://www.koolance.com/water-cooling/product_info.php?product_id=668) Exos-2.5, Black with two (
http://www.koolance.com/water-cooling/product_info.php?product_id=755) CPU-350AC CPU water blocks run in parallel. Given all the heat troubles I have had I think I want to run 1/2" to make sure that I have enough flow volume for optimal heat transfer.
On a side note, does anyone have any experience with the barb-type vs. compression-type hose fittings ? (ref. (
http://www.koolance.com/water-cooling/default.php?cPath=62_63_100) http://www.koolance.com/water-cooling/default.php?cPath=62_63_100)
Oh, and since I have a Thermaltake Armor case, I'm also considering the Thermaltake offerings for pump and radiator (Aquabay M5, TMG 1 Radiator). They are only 3/8" connectors, but the difference between 1/2" and 3/8" tubing water flow isn't that great that I think I absolutely have to have 1/2" ... do I? And the MTBF on the Thermaltake pump is 80,000 hours, while it it 50,000 on the Koolance pump ...
Thanks in advance for any and all advice.
LarryG on 18/10/2009 at 14:54
By the by, If I wanted to stay with air cooling, from what I have read at the Asus Motherboard forum, I would need to install Thermalright IFX-14's. The attach snaps show what they look like installed on the L1N64-SLI WS board. The only problem is that they would not fit in my case! :laff: Not to mention that over time, I bet that the weight of those coolers would crack the board.:eek:
bikerdude on 18/10/2009 at 16:24
Hi Larry
Thats some monster Cpu/mobo setup you have there... which would partly explain the temps.
Are you going to just cool the CPu's or the northbridge and GFX card as well..?
And secondly TT whats the exact armor case model, so we can havfe a look at the TT WC kits designed to fit that case...
LarryG on 18/10/2009 at 18:26
Thanks Bikerdude.
My case is a (
http://www.thermaltakeusa.com/Product.aspx?S=1123&ID=1407) Thermaltake Armor Extreme Edition, except that instead of the two channel air guides on the door, I have 2 90mm fans mounted there, and I don't have the 90mm exhast fan at the top ... there was no room for it with my Corsair HX1000W power supply (I have 7 internal hard drives).
I was planning to start with just the CPUs, since they are where I think the troubles lie. I have read that the northbridge runs extra hot on this board, but I figure if I pump the heat from the CPUs out of the case, that should cool down the ambient temp of the interior significantly.
I want to have sufficient pump/radiator capacity to address other devices later on should that become necessary. I'm so fed up with the CPU heat that I would rather be significantly over capacity than under capacity. I have read in a couple of places that with just two CPUs a 700 Watt capable system should be enough. But these CPUs are HOT. So I figure somthing on the order of 850 - 1000 Watts of cooling would be better and give me enough reserves for future expansion. What do you think?
TBE on 18/10/2009 at 19:45
Are you using thermal paste between the coolers and the processors? Some AMD coolers come with thermal paste already applied, and some do not. If you don't have thermal paste, you may be getting these kinds of temps, or shutdowns. Also, too much or too little thermal paste is bad too.
I'm just trying to trouble-shoot the first thing that would cause a high temp like this. I applaud your courage to try liquid cooling, but it's a risky business. First assemble and run your liquid cooling OUTSIDE of your case. A water leak into your processors and video cards will not be cheap to repair.
Go with the barb fittings. 7/16 tubing, 1/2 barbs.
LarryG on 18/10/2009 at 20:02
Quote Posted by TBE
Are you using thermal paste between the coolers and the processors? Some AMD coolers come with thermal paste already applied, and some do not. If you don't have thermal paste, you may be getting these kinds of temps, or shutdowns. Also, too much or too little thermal paste is bad too.
I'm just trying to trouble-shoot the first thing that would cause a high temp like this. I applaud your courage to try liquid cooling, but it's a risky business. First assemble and run your liquid cooling OUTSIDE of your case. A water leak into your processors and video cards will not be cheap to repair.
Go with the barb fittings. 7/16 tubing, 1/2 barbs.
Yes. I have cleaned up the CPUs and used fresh thermal paste everytime I try new coolers. Thanks for the thought though.
Liquid cooling has come a long way in the past few years. There are even low conductivity -- sometimes called called "non conductive" -- coolants to minimize the risk should leaks develop. But that is why I have tried everything else I could think of first to lower the CPU temps. Unfortunately, I have run out of options, as have most others using this board with those CPUs. I think liquid cooling is now a lower risk than the risk of continued random blue screens when the CPUs overheat.
Renzatic on 19/10/2009 at 15:52
I just got through helping a friend install his liquid cooling system a couple days ago. He piecemealed it together using nothing but exhaustedly researched brand name parts that'd fit together well and do a better job that most of the preassembled kits. Besides mounting the overly huge pump and radiator inside the case (which was a whore), the thing was surprisingly easy to setup, test, and run.
I'll ask him what parts he used and report back to you here if you're interested.
dj_ivocha on 19/10/2009 at 19:46
Quote Posted by LarryG
brand name parts do a lot better job than preassembled kits.
Fix'd
(
http://www.hardwareluxx.de/community/showpost.php?p=11000010&postcount=1486) Here are some pictures of my PC. I have two loops, which run like this:
Loop 1 (Black Tygon tubing): Laing DDC pump -> waterfilter -> Single radiator (front) -> GMR plexiglas flowmeter -> ASUS Fusion block (the northbridge) -> EK 8800GT -> Single radiator (back) -> D-Tek Fuzion V2 -> Thermochill PA120.3 triple radiator (top) -> XSPC 5.25" Bay reservoir -> Laing pump
Loop 2 (Orange tubing): Pump (Alphacool Eheim Station 600) -> Single radiator (bottom) -> Silentstar HD Dual HDD cooler -> pump (some day I might put a RAM block in this loop as well - not that I need it, but it's fun)
Even with two loops and fans on all radiators, I literally can't hear my PC or the HDDs running - I have to get to about 50cm from it to finally hear a very low hum of the pumps and some fans. And it could be even quieter still, as I can turn off half the fans and still maintain great temps. The fans on the triple radiator are (
http://www.watercoolinguk.co.uk/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=41_68&products_id=993) Noiseblocker Multiframe S2, since they are a bit more powerful and that's my main radiator, the other three fans are (
http://www.watercoolinguk.co.uk/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=41_68&products_id=994) Noiseblocker Multiframe S1. They all run at 12v because I can't be bothered to run them at 7v and they are quiet enough as it is.
As for your examples, I'd advise against that Exos all-in-one package - for that price you can get a lot better performance and quieter operation most of the time. Unless looks is really important to you, as I admit it does look pretty sweet.
I haven't heard about those CPU coolers until now and thus don't know how they perform, but I'd advise against going for an all too restrictive flow. As long as you get about 60+ liters per hour, you are good to go, especially if you won't be striving for breaking all overclocking records. Restrictive flow means that a more powerful (== noisy) pump is required. My cooler is a (
http://www.watercoolinguk.co.uk/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=961) D-Tek Fuzion v2, which is barely restrictive at all, yet still ranks as one of the best performers out there, at least it did a year ago.
Also I'd rather not run any parts of the loop in parallel, except maybe blocks that cool less "important" stuff, like eventual RAM or south bridge blocks, and even then I'd advise against it).
Don't bother with "non-conducting" coolant - it will be a lot more expensive and/or will probably decrease the performance of your loop and/or will still not be entirely dielectric so you still won't be completely protected. Just choose the right fittings and make sure you fasten everything securely. Those barb fittings (with suitable hose clamps!) should do the trick. Other than that, distilled water and some anti-algae additive will be just fine.
And contrary to what TBE suggested, assemble everything IN PLACE, but connect the pump to another power supply and run the loop for a day with the PC off. Put a couple of napkins or something under all water blocks and everywhere your tubing plugs in whatever fittings. If you test everything outside the case, you risk making some mistake after you finally assemble it in the case and still frying your PC.
Oh, and unless you really want the best performance from your loop and don't care about the noise, get a radiator with low air resistance (one whose fins aren't packed too tightly), like my Thermochill, or even better, (
http://www.watercoolinguk.co.uk/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=37_73&products_id=1238) this one. Not that it's much more powerful than the Thermochill, it just has standard dimensions for all mounting holes, so you can fit all kinds of fan grills and fittings on it. Rads with lower amount of fpi (fins per inch) allow you to use weaker and thus quieter fans.
Some other suggestions: Don't mix aluminum and copper in your loop! Go with all-copper blocks and stainless steel fittings to avoid corrosion. Use a filter like me, because otherwise your blocks WILL clog and you'll have to take the whole loop apart every 3-6 months for a full clean up. My PC has been running like that for 10 months now and I only took out and cleaned the filter out 2 months ago (though it was pretty clogged and my flow was pretty much nonexistant - around 30l/h and still it was enough). Get a flowmeter, preferably one with an electronic sensor to plug into a fan socket on your mainboard, so you can get some advance warning when your loop starts getting clogged. Don't get the smallest reservoir you can get - powerful pumps create vortexes in small reservoirs and increase the noise, and in extreme cases they can even get damaged if the vortexes are big enough for the pump to suck in air as well. Put your pump directly after the reservoir - other than that, it doesn't matter in what order you put everything else - blocks and rads and flowmeters etc., because the difference in water temperature is minute at best - no more than 1-2 degrees in any case.
LarryG on 20/10/2009 at 00:31
Do you know if the D-Tek Fuzion v2 would fit my CPU and board without having to pull the board and install a new backplate? I'm just not up for that. I have 2 Athlon™ 64 FX-74 dual core CPUs ...
dj_ivocha on 20/10/2009 at 10:04
Not sure, but I read somewhere that Socket F uses the same mounting holes as S939, so if that's the case, it will work. You can ask (
http://www.dtekcustoms.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=210) D-TEK though, if you want to be sure.
Oh, one other thing - IIRC Koolance used to price their items a bit on the high side, so before you go and buy everything from there, make sure you compare the prices with a few other shops too. Unfortunately I don't know any US shops so I can't help you there.