LarryG on 7/5/2015 at 21:51
I have similar concerns here. These are very nice textures, but are they replacements for the originals? I don't think so.
Necrobob on 8/5/2015 at 07:13
Brilliant overall, except for the pixelated cobwebs.
LarryG on 8/5/2015 at 13:23
[ATTACH=CONFIG]2119[/ATTACH]
It may help rescaling the original and putting it side by side with your version to compare. As you can see the window ledge is not present in the original, the frame starts a little below the top of the texture, and the window is longer.
Here you can see the proportions are wrong in places as well as the surface texture and shadowing / depth of the material.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]2120[/ATTACH]
LarryG on 8/5/2015 at 18:31
One other thought to consider: the textures aren't always used full frame. Some times they are used for just a portion of the texture. IIRC a slice of oven2 is sometimes used in steps to visually provide a step ledge above an inset vertical. If you change where the ledge is in the frame, you can ruin that usage. It really is important to keep the proportions of the texture elements correct.
